Tuesday, 1 September 2009

Of cow heads and arrogant Muslims

By Prof Mohd Tajuddin Haji Mohd Rasdi

I wish to comment on the 'cow head' incident in Shah Alam. As a Muslim and as a Malaysian citizen I do not support such a wanton display of disrespect for Islam and for Malaysia.
As a Muslim, my readings of Islam and the Prophet Muhammad's traditions or hadiths have taught me to respect animals and other religions.

With respect to animals, the Prophet warned Muslims against overburdening animals in carrying objects. The Prophet explained a story of how a prostitute was forgiven her sins by the simple act of giving a thirsty dog a drink.

The cow is one of the animals which Muslims slaughter not just for food but also as a sacrificial offering of our thankfulness to Allah as well as remembering Abraham's 'sacrifice' of his son Ismail.

The cow is thus 'holy' to Muslims as well as to Hindus. Muslims sacrifice a cow for the aqiqah ceremony or during the Qurban celebrations.

Thus as a Muslim, we must respect animals that become our food as well as our symbolic act of sacrifice.Standing or putting once's foot on a dead cow is a 'biadab' act that speaks of a person steeped in racial bigotry and of a person low in education of Islam.

With respect to other religions, there were occasions where the Prophet taught me about my attitude towards them. Once, the Prophet stood up as a sign of respect when the body of a Jew was carried to the grave.

When dispatching the army to a campaign, the Prophet warned the soldiers from desecrating houses of worships, those who reside in them, the young and the old and even trees should not be cut down if necessary.

Never had the Prophet taught me to desecrate another person's religion. The great Indonesian scholar Hamka wrote in his magnum opus, Tafsir Al-Azhar that there are hundreds of thousands of 'Nabi' and they might even be the founders of other religions.

It is common to find other religious faiths making fun of Islam and Muslims but as a Muslim I will never be allowed by my religion to make fun of other religions much less to desecrate them.

As a Malaysian citizen, I wish to ask why these people who showed such contempt for the religion of the Hindus not be arrested under the Sedition Act?

Were these people given permits by the police? If so why were they granted permits to desecrate another religion? Why were they not stopped and told to disperse? If Hindus can tolerate the Muslim call for prayers five times a day for the rest of their lives, what disruption can a Hindu temple be?

I live next to a Hindu Temple about 150 meters away and I observe a procession thrice or twice a year. It is quiet 362 days of the year.

Lastly, if these residents were proven to be members of any political party or parties, their membership should be revoked in order to ensure that we should not tolerate any political entity that uses racial hatred as their means of achieving political ends.

If not, then the said party or parties should be outlawed and their registration terminated immediately.

After more than 50 years of merdeka, I still cannot raise five children without the threat of racial disharmony and hatred. What does that say about our present leadership and future of our country?

7 comments:

  1. In a democracy, the people have the right to peaceful demonstrations. Now why all the fuss and “scolding”?
    During the demonstration, the police and FRU present did not see it as an offense as the 50 odd demonstrators is only carrying a cow-head; they are not holding candles or wearing black, which is not allowed and they do not need a police permit…..umm

    Even our home minister told reporters that the police allowed the demonstrators to proceed because the numbers of protestors were small and defended and justified last Friday's cow-head demonstration. He also said that if the controversy could be resolved, there would be no need to penalise any party.

    However our PM of 1 Malaysia pointed out today that only the police and Attorney-General can decide on the fate of the cow-head protestors. Bear in mind, these 2 institutions are very well respected in the eyes of the world.

    Because of such "universality" in values, now I am really at a lost as to what a Cow is and what is a Bull.
    Probably or perhaps our friend Lim can help us to understand this issue better.

    Hello Kawan Lim,

    In your own words regarding the purpose of Jimmy’s blog, Jimmy has now brought up this matter to “create awareness amongst us, the residents, the MC, and also GE Tan mgnt”.

    Would you be kind enough to share with us some “good useful bit of information” that is hard to come by from people like us? We would be pleased to hear something constructive from you to guide us. Please do not turn us down as “busy is an excuse for not eager to do something”, since you can do it in a healthy way. We urge you to step or “stand forward and be counted” now.

    You said “to give is to receive, hopefully we will see more residents involve positively in working towards the improvement of PG” and I say, also Malaysia, since those people commenting at MT are only “cheap and free scolding” type. In a way, agree.

    So, can you now “walk the talk” for us, kawan Lim?????

    cat

    ReplyDelete
  2. i support peaceful demo, but not this way. they should know how to respect others race/religion. What if others ppl hurt their races/religion? How they feel.
    Our politician should be role model but they always use race & religion to achieve their polical agenda.
    Hope less tension on race & religion in Malaysia.

    tt

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi tt,

    Love your comments and agree with every word you said. Now I know the answer, it's not a cow but a BULL!!!!...LOL

    cat

    ReplyDelete
  4. The home minister, Kerismudin mentioned that it was a misunderstanding. The organizers (now they are known as organizers, wah lau eh) did not know about the Bull Head, but the world saw how these "do not know anything about the Bull Head" people spat and stepped on the animal's head on video...

    ReplyDelete
  5. Busy.
    IMAGINE.

    Lim

    ReplyDelete
  6. I really appreciate Jimmy for putting up the article by Prof Mohd Tajuddin. It makes me feel better that there's still understanding Muslim friends out there that do respect other races/religions. At least there's still hope.... MH

    ReplyDelete
  7. Oh….after all the gibberish statements, he is now asking for stern action against those involved in the cow-head protest. “Flip-Flop” at its best, wish it was “Hip-Hop”, at least it will be entertaining. How their minds work is still a mystery to me.

    Until such time when the majority is educated under a different system where they can be in the state of mind to improve self-esteem and change the mindset to a dynamically global mindset, there is no way; we are going to change the present political landscape where the bottom-line is to obtain “power” at all cost just to control the Nation’s coffer. I shudder at the thoughts for our generations to come.

    Democracy is a luxury political system, only sustainable in countries where the people's mindset is progressive and perpetually or at least consistently in advance mode.

    God bless Malaysia.

    cat

    ReplyDelete